The Conjunction Fallacy
The Conjunction Fallacy: A Lens for Creating Clearer and Stronger Photographs
The conjunction fallacy is a cognitive bias in which people incorrectly assume that specific conditions are more likely than general ones. Photographers must grasp this concept.
Photographers try to capture a complex scene, including more elements they think will enhance the story or emotional impact. This often leads to mistakes. Instead of making a stronger photograph, adding extra details can dilute the photograph's power, making it less clear and more difficult for viewers to understand.
By recognizing and overcoming the conjunction fallacy, photographers can streamline their approach and make stronger photos that communicate effectively. Here’s how the conjunction fallacy can guide better photographic decisions.
Emphasize Core Elements Over Unnecessary Details
A common mistake in photography is including too many elements within a single frame. Photographers to believe adding more items—foreground elements, background details, multiple subjects—will provide a more complete narrative. However, the more elements that compete within a frame, the more diluted the main subject becomes, making it harder for viewers to focus on what matters.
To overcome this, aim to focus on core elements, deciding on a single subject and complementary features that reinforce it. When photographing a person, for example, there’s often no need to capture every aspect of their environment; instead, choose a few details that support the subject. Suppose your subject is a person sitting in a café. In that case, you might select the steam rising from their coffee or their reflection in the window rather than including every patron or piece of furniture. This approach simplifies the photograph, directing attention to the main story or feeling you want to convey.
Use a Singular Mood or Storyline
The conjunction fallacy can also trap photographers into thinking they should capture multiple moods or stories within a single image. Each message becomes muddled when attempting to communicate many ideas, emotions, or stories in a single frame, reducing the photograph's emotional impact. Viewers struggle to decode the intended narrative, leading to a disconnection from the image.
Commit to a single mood or storyline. Decide before you shoot what you want the viewer to feel or understand. If you capture a rainy street, decide whether the mood should be somber, hopeful, or mysterious. Focus on elements that support this mood, like reflections in puddles or a single ray of sunlight breaking through. By narrowing the emotional intent, you avoid the conjunction fallacy and deliver a clear message, making the image more accessible and resonant.
Simplify Composition by Minimizing Competing Elements
Photo compositions often suffer from conjunction fallacy when too many focal points compete for attention. Including multiple leading lines, centers of interest, or contrasting colors may overwhelm the viewer, confusing the photograph. Each additional element divides the viewer’s attention. Instead of a cohesive composition, the image risks becoming a chaotic visual experience.
To counter this:
Simplify your composition.
Identify the main point of interest and composing around it, using supporting elements sparingly.
Use the rule of thirds or leading lines to guide the viewer’s eye without overwhelming them with competing features.
Instead of including every detail in a landscape photograph, focus on a single dominant feature, such as a mountain peak or a distinctive tree, and use the surrounding landscape as a supporting element. This simplicity helps to clarify the photograph and allows viewers to appreciate the central focus without distraction.
Recognize the Limits of Color and Contrast
The conjunction fallacy can also influence how photographers use color and contrast, leading them to believe that more vivid or contrasting colors will enhance the image's visual appeal. While contrast and color variety can make an image eye-catching, too many contrasting colors or textures within one frame can create a discordant effect, making it harder for viewers to find a point of focus.
To avoid this, limit the color palette to a few harmonious colors or let one or two colors dominate the frame. This approach helps with visual unity and reinforces the image's mood. For instance, if photographing a winter scene, cool colors like blues and grays can evoke a sense of coldness and calm, whereas a splash of warm color, like a red scarf on a person, can create a point of interest and contrast without overwhelming the frame. By consciously choosing a restrained palette, photographers can avoid the conjunction fallacy and create a more visually coherent image.
Focus on Storytelling with Selective Details
Photographers often fail when attempting to tell a complex story by including excessive visual details, thinking that more elements will make the narrative more straightforward. Ironically, adding too many details can obscure the story rather than enhance it, as viewers are left deciphering numerous aspects instead of focusing on the key story.
Selective details representing the scene's essence are used to create compelling storytelling images. This selective approach distills the narrative, allowing viewers to grasp the story at a glance without becoming distracted by superfluous details.
Refine Post-Processing Choices
Post-processing, too, can fall prey to the fallacy. Photographers often layer on various effects—high contrast, saturation, vignettes, or sharpening—believing each adjustment will enhance the final image. Too many edits often create an unnatural or overly processed look, detracting from the authenticity of the photograph.
To avoid this pitfall, edit with restraint. Decide on a primary adjustment that best enhances the photograph’s intent, whether boosting the contrast for depth, adjusting the white balance for mood, or increasing clarity on the subject. Limiting post-processing adjustments maintains the photograph’s authenticity, allowing the original elements to stand out rather than overwhelming the image with artificial effects. This controlled editing reinforces the visual story, helping the photograph feel more genuine and direct.
Conclusion
The conjunction fallacy reminds photographers to simplify, guiding them to create more intentional and impactful images by focusing on the essential elements. Emphasizing core components, limiting moods and stories, simplifying composition, restraining color use, and focusing on selective details all contribute to avoiding unnecessary complexity. When photographers recognize that "less is more" and resist the urge to overcomplicate, their work gains clarity and strength, making it easier for viewers to connect with the image.
By embracing the conjunction fallacy as a mental model, photographers learn to pare down each shot to its most impactful aspects. This approach enhances the overall quality of their work. It helps communicate clear, resonant messages, making every image a more powerful and memorable experience.
PhotoCamp Daily is always free! But you can pledge support at any time.
Consider subscribing to The Westerville News and My Final Photo News. Also recommended is Into the Morning by Krista Steele.
My Final Photo News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support photography and commentary, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.